I thought this hit the nail on the head. I don’t think Carrick is at the level, I really hoped he might be. But his hiring is a symptom of deeper problems at the club and the same systems and processes aren’t going to fix it.
mashfordfc on
There can be multiple problems, Carrick is one of many
Whispperr on
Carrick apologists are in full force today.
Our board is bad, and one of the bas decisions they made was give a bad coach the full time job.
florplegorp on
Why can’t we have multiple problems? I think we’ve got room for all of them
cosmologues on
I’m okay with Wilcox getting criticized. But let’s get Carrick out too.
linkfollowlink on
I don’t think Carrick is good enough, he has no clear pattern of play and hasn’t improved his players by coaching.
That said, good to see that Lisandro Matinez’s interview has publicly brought pressure to those above Carrick, they are not hiding behind the managers anymore.
NMI_INT on
It’s both. Carrick should not have been made the permanent manager. He’s clearly out of his depth.
Today was slightly better but overall this season we look slow and disorganized.
Substitutions have been late and baffling at points. We don’t look well drilled, tactics appear to be nonexistent.
That’s on carrick.
Summer transfer window has been mediocre except for maybe baleba.
That’s on wilcox et al.
But my goodness, even with what we have today we should be doing a lot better.
So yes, it’s both.
Panda-768 on
carrick started with 4 midfielders against lead and we still didn’t dominate possession or anything else for that matter, pathetic
SankarshanaV on
Yeah no. Both Carrick and the management are problems. Carrick needs to be sacked asap and so do the management.
A failed manager from the Championship who is completely out of his depth is not someone I’d like to manage a club like Man Utd.
L__K on
“There is another problem” doesn’t instantly mean “this other thing isn’t a problem”
frankestofshadows on
So many people expecting miracles from Carrick. We are not a top 4 aide. The sooner people realise that, the better. We are not performing well obviously, but if you give a builder a pair of pliers, he can’t hammer in a nail effectively.
The issues have always been the board and when we sacked Ashworth, it was further evidence of that. This sub lauds Ole, yet he had a similar run after his appointment. We were not playing great football, but we all have him time.
We can go ahead and sack Carrick, but no one has an alternative. The ones people have mentioned would create more issues than fixes.
I-Shiki-I on
Yeah board bad, but why are we playing counter attack against leeds? 🤡
silky_skills_35 on
How do you solve what is, on revenue versus results, the worst-run club in world football?
– that’s the issue we have, we buy B grade talent for A grade money. We need to start buying Elliott Anderson’s who make a difference, or look for the next talent like Brighton and co do, who have the potential to reach world class performance.
We seem to be stuck in middle ground. And then we can worry about the managers getting the best out of a talented squad, rather than a middling one.
Pierates_Ahoy on
yeah but keeping cunha on the bench until 85′ is.
[deleted] on
[removed]
TommyTook on
It’s also Michael Carrick. He would genuinely struggle to get a job in the Championship and yet he’s somehow still in charge at the biggest club in England
facelessredditer on
Sacking managers mid rebuild is also a problem. Get a new guy in but Conte is the wrong fit – stylistically and for incorporating youth into a squad build out.
Does anyone remember the 2003-06 stretch where it felt like we’re getting further away?
Only once the entire new team was in place with Carrick-VDS-Vidic-Evra cementing their role, could you get the best out of Ferdinand-Rooney-Ronaldo-Scholes-Giggs.
The same team that looked really off it became one of the greatest in PL history.
Wait till the summer if you have to, but get the “right” guy not another big name saviour! Emery has learnt his lessons and paid his dues. Proven himself a talented manager, repeatedly. A manager with talent to get more out of his squads than the sum of their parts.
With the state of the squad and financial situation – Emery is the right fit with the right mentality. He’s not a “big name” but he’s the best man for this job. This is one is as obvious to me as VDS at Fulham or Carlo at Everton! The talent is so bleeding obvious!
kevoofvi on
I’ve seen this cycle so many times I swear it’s because we sold our soul to the devil and the last 13 years has just been purgatory. Like Jesus Christ can be our manager and we’d somehow turn his wine into piss
b_litzkreig on
Both things can be true.
Higher management is shit + manager is shit = performance is shit.
This squad definitely can perform better than whatever we have been showing in recent weeks. Challenge for league title? No. Challenge for Europe? Definitely yes.
Fantastic-Estimate88 on
people cannot understand nuance. the board is shit, terrible track record, the next manager will inherit the same shitshow carrick has. however, carrick should never have been appointed in the first place, and keeping him in post is a continuation of the same mediocrity.
kimochii12 on
Nothing will change until the ownership is changed. They have been working against their own managers to hide their own incompetence.
transient-DAverc on
Worst start in 40 years? Whatever Carrick’s doing, it isn’t helping
JCivX on
Of course a fucking “journalist” is contributing to this “either or” mentality. It’s so fucking dumb. There is plenty of blame to go around, yet a massive share of the discussion is arguments about who is to blame as if anyone here is without blame (including many of the players).
Yes, sacking Carrick is not going to fix the fundamental problems of this club, obviously. But it doesn’t mean Carrick is getting anywhere near enough out of this team in terms of performance or points. He’s been awful in almost every way.
eternali17 on
He exemplifies the incompetence. Wtf.
greennitit on
This sub needs to be retired. It has gotten so bad that [r/Manchester](r/Manchester)United is starting to look okay
malakiangpekpek on
Any reason why Carrick won’t give Amass a chance? Sure Dalot might be the more experienced player but he’s been ass for a while.
kriznone on
Elite level incompetence is the reason Michael Carrick was given the permanent job.
JosePRizaI on
Under Amorim: “its all Amorims fault, Stubborn, 343”
Under Carrick:
1. The players and their mentality
2. Wilcox (yea he sucks)
3. Omar
4. Jim
5. NEVER CARRICK
They be doing tricks on it
MatchHighlights14 on
Playing good but being unlucky in goal scoring is one thing.But this team neither plays good nor create scoring options nor fight nor dominate.The mentality has dropped to a level lower than the Dead Sea.
WorldOfNintend0 on
People seem to forget that carrick had not one but TWO great runs at interim manager. Thats why he got the job. I feel like if it was pure luck, he wouldn’t have been able to do it twice.
31 Comments
I thought this hit the nail on the head. I don’t think Carrick is at the level, I really hoped he might be. But his hiring is a symptom of deeper problems at the club and the same systems and processes aren’t going to fix it.
There can be multiple problems, Carrick is one of many
Carrick apologists are in full force today.
Our board is bad, and one of the bas decisions they made was give a bad coach the full time job.
Why can’t we have multiple problems? I think we’ve got room for all of them
I’m okay with Wilcox getting criticized. But let’s get Carrick out too.
I don’t think Carrick is good enough, he has no clear pattern of play and hasn’t improved his players by coaching.
That said, good to see that Lisandro Matinez’s interview has publicly brought pressure to those above Carrick, they are not hiding behind the managers anymore.
It’s both. Carrick should not have been made the permanent manager. He’s clearly out of his depth.
Today was slightly better but overall this season we look slow and disorganized.
Substitutions have been late and baffling at points. We don’t look well drilled, tactics appear to be nonexistent.
That’s on carrick.
Summer transfer window has been mediocre except for maybe baleba.
That’s on wilcox et al.
But my goodness, even with what we have today we should be doing a lot better.
So yes, it’s both.
carrick started with 4 midfielders against lead and we still didn’t dominate possession or anything else for that matter, pathetic
Yeah no. Both Carrick and the management are problems. Carrick needs to be sacked asap and so do the management.
A failed manager from the Championship who is completely out of his depth is not someone I’d like to manage a club like Man Utd.
“There is another problem” doesn’t instantly mean “this other thing isn’t a problem”
So many people expecting miracles from Carrick. We are not a top 4 aide. The sooner people realise that, the better. We are not performing well obviously, but if you give a builder a pair of pliers, he can’t hammer in a nail effectively.
The issues have always been the board and when we sacked Ashworth, it was further evidence of that. This sub lauds Ole, yet he had a similar run after his appointment. We were not playing great football, but we all have him time.
We can go ahead and sack Carrick, but no one has an alternative. The ones people have mentioned would create more issues than fixes.
Yeah board bad, but why are we playing counter attack against leeds? 🤡
How do you solve what is, on revenue versus results, the worst-run club in world football?
– that’s the issue we have, we buy B grade talent for A grade money. We need to start buying Elliott Anderson’s who make a difference, or look for the next talent like Brighton and co do, who have the potential to reach world class performance.
We seem to be stuck in middle ground. And then we can worry about the managers getting the best out of a talented squad, rather than a middling one.
yeah but keeping cunha on the bench until 85′ is.
[removed]
It’s also Michael Carrick. He would genuinely struggle to get a job in the Championship and yet he’s somehow still in charge at the biggest club in England
Sacking managers mid rebuild is also a problem. Get a new guy in but Conte is the wrong fit – stylistically and for incorporating youth into a squad build out.
Does anyone remember the 2003-06 stretch where it felt like we’re getting further away?
Only once the entire new team was in place with Carrick-VDS-Vidic-Evra cementing their role, could you get the best out of Ferdinand-Rooney-Ronaldo-Scholes-Giggs.
The same team that looked really off it became one of the greatest in PL history.
Wait till the summer if you have to, but get the “right” guy not another big name saviour! Emery has learnt his lessons and paid his dues. Proven himself a talented manager, repeatedly. A manager with talent to get more out of his squads than the sum of their parts.
With the state of the squad and financial situation – Emery is the right fit with the right mentality. He’s not a “big name” but he’s the best man for this job. This is one is as obvious to me as VDS at Fulham or Carlo at Everton! The talent is so bleeding obvious!
I’ve seen this cycle so many times I swear it’s because we sold our soul to the devil and the last 13 years has just been purgatory. Like Jesus Christ can be our manager and we’d somehow turn his wine into piss
Both things can be true.
Higher management is shit + manager is shit = performance is shit.
This squad definitely can perform better than whatever we have been showing in recent weeks. Challenge for league title? No. Challenge for Europe? Definitely yes.
people cannot understand nuance. the board is shit, terrible track record, the next manager will inherit the same shitshow carrick has. however, carrick should never have been appointed in the first place, and keeping him in post is a continuation of the same mediocrity.
Nothing will change until the ownership is changed. They have been working against their own managers to hide their own incompetence.
Worst start in 40 years? Whatever Carrick’s doing, it isn’t helping
Of course a fucking “journalist” is contributing to this “either or” mentality. It’s so fucking dumb. There is plenty of blame to go around, yet a massive share of the discussion is arguments about who is to blame as if anyone here is without blame (including many of the players).
Yes, sacking Carrick is not going to fix the fundamental problems of this club, obviously. But it doesn’t mean Carrick is getting anywhere near enough out of this team in terms of performance or points. He’s been awful in almost every way.
He exemplifies the incompetence. Wtf.
This sub needs to be retired. It has gotten so bad that [r/Manchester](r/Manchester)United is starting to look okay
Any reason why Carrick won’t give Amass a chance? Sure Dalot might be the more experienced player but he’s been ass for a while.
Elite level incompetence is the reason Michael Carrick was given the permanent job.
Under Amorim: “its all Amorims fault, Stubborn, 343”
Under Carrick:
1. The players and their mentality
2. Wilcox (yea he sucks)
3. Omar
4. Jim
5. NEVER CARRICK
They be doing tricks on it
Playing good but being unlucky in goal scoring is one thing.But this team neither plays good nor create scoring options nor fight nor dominate.The mentality has dropped to a level lower than the Dead Sea.
People seem to forget that carrick had not one but TWO great runs at interim manager. Thats why he got the job. I feel like if it was pure luck, he wouldn’t have been able to do it twice.
Like carrick isnt incompetent as well