Classify the above as: Fantastic, Value for Money, Not Worth it, Flop

My list:

Fantastic: Kane, Lucho, Olise

Value for Money: Upamecano, Lucas, De Ligt

Not Worth It: Tolisso, Sane

Flop: Kim, Palhinha

What would be yours?

by Weary_Cable_3780

17 Comments

  1. Not a great betting average. Lucas was terrible considering his fee at the time and injuries

  2. Fantastic – Kane, Diaz, Olise, javi Martinez
    Good – Upamecano, De Ligt, Kim
    Not worth it – Hernandez, sane, tolisso
    Flop – Palhinha

  3. soccermodsareshit on

    Kane-Diaz-Olise: Great

    Upamecano: Very Good

    De Ligt-Hernandez-Kim: Ok/Good

    Tolisso-Sane-Palhinha: unlucky/meh

  4. Tolisso was worth the money quality wise, he just was so unlucky with injuries.

    And Kim is not a flop at all.

  5. Helpful_Virus_2077 on

    To me Lucas was flop and absolutely waste of money. To me he was a flop considering how much he did cost. He was usually just injured.

    Upamecano started quite poorly, but now he is great. Imo he is more than worth it.

  6. Lucas was certainly a great player but injured all the time and kind of made it impossible to build a solid defense because of that. Therefore not worth the money.

    I would say most transfers were reasonable. Tolisso is similar to Lucas – you cant predict that a player is injured all the time.

    Sané was worth his money but people thought he is worth way more.

    Kim is worth his money aswell.

  7. fastwalkernope on

    I don’t see how De Ligt is not a flop. He was not that impressive here and was sold for a very high loss, all while having a high wage. And I say this as someone who was hoping he would become the club’s next vice captain 🙁

  8. Palhinha was a regret as soon as he signed. I know it was a Tuchel player but they got him after knowing Tuchel was leaving.