Wouldn’t it better to sign a RB. Someone who can come on when Nunes is unable to play?
DapperSpecial2865 on
Both are expensive. Anderson would be better.
I’d take both if Rodri left but I don’t want that
NavJongUnPlayandwon on
anderson. he solves a lot of the problems. and plus we’d see a lot more games of nico g and rodri on the same pitch when we sign him.
Ecstatic-Spare-6638 on
Anderson
Quick9Ben5 on
Anderson but for the love of christ play Nico Gonzales
escalibur on
We dont need Tonali when we have Rodri and Nico. Anderson all the way.
eltee27 on
This sub: Nico G doesn’t play enough.
This sub: O’Reilly needs to start more in midfield
This sub: Reijndeers needs to start more.
This sub: Cherki needs to start more.
Also this sub: Let’s sign more midfielders
MZero_0 on
If both Rodri and Silva leave then I want both. If only Silva leaves then get Anderson.
pacothebattlefly on
United are rumoured to be in for Tonali, that’s a bidding war we don’t need
Noah-XMutindi on
both
Y4That on
Totally different players, its not like they are substitute for each other
Anderson is similar to rodri, deep playmaker while tonali is a proper b2b 8
sexmarshines on
Tonali is a special player. I wanted him when he left AC Milan. I’d go for him if we only need one midfielder. Both him and Anderson if we need two.
As others have said Rodri may leave with Bernardo this summer. That’s the vibe I’m getting at least. He doesn’t look happy for months now.
Fabulous_Ad631 on
We need to sign a solid rb .
Not a midfielder man.
IcyClover3598 on
Tonali easy
South_Fish on
Rice is the best
Key-Lengthiness9559 on
I think Tonali is headed back to Italy
souviks1998 on
And*
wkdsoul on
Yes.
Either_Crab6526 on
Elliot Anderson 100%
pandadoubl on
Tonali is budget Anderson, class player, I’d say just as good currently but Elliot has the higher ceiling and he’s English (HG quota), if the club doesn’t want to break the bank, Tonali is a solid solid option
Oogway17_ on
Anderson is coming to city thats for sure.
Not sure about Tonali
Business-Spring760 on
No more fucking fraudulent signings
KDBae on
Tonali is Arsenal bound
minimus67 on
Anderson. Here is a chart showing how he ranks on key metrics vs. other PL midfielders this season.
My only concern is that Pep is often very slow to “onboard” incoming DMs because he is so demanding and specific in what he wants from them. If Pep stays next season (admittedly, there’s a big question mark about that) and Anderson arrives as a no 6, I doubt he will be allowed to venture as far forward as he does at Forest. That means his chance creation will probably drop off.
What’s odd is that from a defensive standpoint in the PL, Nico G has performed as well as Anderson. Nico’s defensive contributions are 87th vs 76th percentile for Anderson (and a relatively mediocre 61st percentile for Rodri, who is seemingly undroppable now that he’s back from injury.) Nico ranks 90th vs 87th percentile for Anderson on aerial duels won, 97th vs 96th percentile on touches, and 45th percentile, only a tad below Anderson’s 48th percentile, on goals.
Despite Nico G’s defensive strengths, Pep has mothballed him at City. At one point, Pep was critical of him, saying he runs too much, and Pep clearly prefers a rusty, somewhat sluggish Rodri, even though City’s form was better than it is now back when Nico G was regularly starting. If City buys Anderson, I suspect Nico G. will request a transfer, which is likely to be granted because he’s clearly good enough to be a starter at many other clubs.
HalfLonely77645 on
The only right answer- None.
Unarchy on
I’ve heard Napoli have a pretty good midfielder. Maybe we could go for him instead?
33 Comments
Tonali
Elliot
Elliot all day
Anderson
Wouldn’t it better to sign a RB. Someone who can come on when Nunes is unable to play?
Both are expensive. Anderson would be better.
I’d take both if Rodri left but I don’t want that
anderson. he solves a lot of the problems. and plus we’d see a lot more games of nico g and rodri on the same pitch when we sign him.
Anderson
Anderson but for the love of christ play Nico Gonzales
We dont need Tonali when we have Rodri and Nico. Anderson all the way.
This sub: Nico G doesn’t play enough.
This sub: O’Reilly needs to start more in midfield
This sub: Reijndeers needs to start more.
This sub: Cherki needs to start more.
Also this sub: Let’s sign more midfielders
If both Rodri and Silva leave then I want both. If only Silva leaves then get Anderson.
United are rumoured to be in for Tonali, that’s a bidding war we don’t need
both
Totally different players, its not like they are substitute for each other
Anderson is similar to rodri, deep playmaker while tonali is a proper b2b 8
Tonali is a special player. I wanted him when he left AC Milan. I’d go for him if we only need one midfielder. Both him and Anderson if we need two.
As others have said Rodri may leave with Bernardo this summer. That’s the vibe I’m getting at least. He doesn’t look happy for months now.
We need to sign a solid rb .
Not a midfielder man.
Tonali easy
Rice is the best
I think Tonali is headed back to Italy
And*
Yes.
Elliot Anderson 100%
Tonali is budget Anderson, class player, I’d say just as good currently but Elliot has the higher ceiling and he’s English (HG quota), if the club doesn’t want to break the bank, Tonali is a solid solid option
Anderson is coming to city thats for sure.
Not sure about Tonali
No more fucking fraudulent signings
Tonali is Arsenal bound
Anderson. Here is a chart showing how he ranks on key metrics vs. other PL midfielders this season.
https://preview.redd.it/hbxt8idf01qg1.jpeg?width=663&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b8c8d6e030c459880361ad8907a56684e1f925f8
My only concern is that Pep is often very slow to “onboard” incoming DMs because he is so demanding and specific in what he wants from them. If Pep stays next season (admittedly, there’s a big question mark about that) and Anderson arrives as a no 6, I doubt he will be allowed to venture as far forward as he does at Forest. That means his chance creation will probably drop off.
What’s odd is that from a defensive standpoint in the PL, Nico G has performed as well as Anderson. Nico’s defensive contributions are 87th vs 76th percentile for Anderson (and a relatively mediocre 61st percentile for Rodri, who is seemingly undroppable now that he’s back from injury.) Nico ranks 90th vs 87th percentile for Anderson on aerial duels won, 97th vs 96th percentile on touches, and 45th percentile, only a tad below Anderson’s 48th percentile, on goals.
Despite Nico G’s defensive strengths, Pep has mothballed him at City. At one point, Pep was critical of him, saying he runs too much, and Pep clearly prefers a rusty, somewhat sluggish Rodri, even though City’s form was better than it is now back when Nico G was regularly starting. If City buys Anderson, I suspect Nico G. will request a transfer, which is likely to be granted because he’s clearly good enough to be a starter at many other clubs.
The only right answer- None.
I’ve heard Napoli have a pretty good midfielder. Maybe we could go for him instead?
Wharton is so clear
Enzo