Is Aaron Ramsdale a good loan move for Newcastle United?
In This Video
– Eddie Howe on Alexander Isak
– Aaron Ramsdale to Newcastle
– Why it makes sense
– Why it doesn’t make sense
– What would he bring?
– Comparison to Nick Pope
#HWTL #Geordies #NUFC #NewcastleUnited #Toon #ToonArmy #Mags #Magpies #PremierLeague #Ekitike #TransferWindow #Football #Herewego #Southampton #UCL #chmapionsleague
44 Comments
Not exciting but i hope he does well. Any chance you can apply for a job at Newcastle? 😂
Doing a cracking job kidda 👍
If there was ever a video I didn't want to see on this channel then its a Pope v Ramsdale comparison…. God that's depressing…..
You really need to become a scout for nufc
Yes to buying Sesko if that is possible, he is younger and taller and has not reached his potential yet! No to Watkins who is 29 going on 30! NUFC have an issue with aging players! We need to get younger!
Hi Antonio love the content, you spot on with information and have a great grasp of breaking down what strengths players have, suprised the club haven't offered you a job in a advisory role.
Have you done a review of Kalimuendo from Rennes apparently he going Brighton, im hoping we get him as think he a good player that we could turn into a world class striker and believe we must have a bigger pull than Brighton, but then again its Chelsea feeder club maybe he sees that as his preferred choice, seems strange we dont go for this type of player instead of ones who are established and will go for bigger wages to the cartel clubs.
Amazing analysis
Top video as per 👍 ramsdale is a liability imo. But if he’s only on loan maybe it’s not a bad idea. We’re absolutely desperate for defenders and we’re not even linked with anyone, that’s massively concerning. I think we end up with ramsdale, Wissa and one other hopefully a midfielder.
It’s just Eddie Howe dishing out jobs to has beens from Bournemouth and his mates have had a few bob out of the toon disgraceful we are supposed to be going forward with the project not backwards
What is very concerning is having and paying for 6 shot stoppers! Get rid of 3 shot stoppers!
This is what upsets me about management, paying for 6 goal keepers! What a waste of money! Blatant mis-management!!!
Strange signing in Ramsdale but as always I trust Eddie. I’m praying we sign Sisko but I have to say my hopes have diminished since Man U entered the hunt.
Isn’t Hope’s poor save metric diving to his left due to recurring shoulder injuries. What’s Ramsdale’s excuse?
Good deal but not the top story is it. Smoke screen because of isak. Sesko priority. Wissa on strike. Isak one more season bro.
I like it… mainly because it's a Loan, but let's see what he can do. Eddie might actually get more out of him. 🤷🏿♂️ Plus, I'm a little lighter on GK stats because as a GK myself, you can't blame every conceded goal on the GK. Especially on a team like Southampton. Regardless, maybe this would be a Win Win for both the player and club.
IDK, just trying to be Optimistic. Our Defense I feel are not as bad as Bournemouth, Southampton, etc. and it's probably a reason that he rejected Sunderland. A Gk has to have a decent defense in front of him.
Sesco 💯
Another great video Antonio. Proper analysis and NOT just rehashed news found from usual sources. PIF need to make Antonio their next signing of the summer on the scouting side, thats a signing we’d all get behind.
For me, to progress, we need a shot stopper who is comfortable in possession and can play out from the back, not a keeper who can do one or the other.
If popes injured then we have a number 2 ? Sorry dubs 🤔
If Isak goes, do you think there would be any useful makeweights in the deal like Harvey Elliot for example?
Great video Antonio. Do you think that this means to that Yasir is putting his foot down and making sure business gets done? If that is the case then this is hopefully the first of a set of deals that strengthen the squad.
If practice makes perfect then last year Ramsdale had a lot of practice! He’s a top keeper and at 27 he’s got his best years ahead of to get even better. Good business I’d say.
He is an upgrade on Dubravka. If you cant make the ceiling higher, you bring the floor closer to the ceiling. Smart signing on loan as frees up money for other positions
Id prefer Woltemade over Sesko and i dont want Watkins. Or Ramsdale.
No team changes Goalkeeper to suit a game just doesn’t work, you sound like Arteta. The keeper is the foundation of the defence and also sets the tempo of the game, changing this upsets the balance.
Quality vid. Subbed.
Hidden gems all day long!
Mango is the boyo
Someone has to make sense 😂😂
We have ageing squad no way we should consider players like Ramsdale or Watkins, we need to buy young develop and trade.
14 years with the fat bastard have learned me to love the players we get. Not get the players we love. Ramsdale is a solid goalie. If we get him we can ship out demos and martin. (Kennedy and ruddy is just around to fill up slots. Although ruddy is a safe 3 option) And call it this season sorted on goalie post. And go for a super goalie next season. Super analysis Antonio. Keep up the great work you do.
Would have been good to see his stats at Arsenal since he had a better team in front of him. Good job though, I think it’s a good signing and potentially better than Trafford in the short term 🤔
Ornstein has just confirmed this signing
You’ve been my go to for this transfer window boss.
Fuck Manchester United, Ollie Watkins is staying at Villa unless a quality replacement striker is lined up & Emery is confident they can pick up where Watkins left,very unlikely I think,but stranger things happen, it's virtually impossible to find a decent striker right now & one with a premier league proven record is basically non existent at the moment hence the prices clubs with a striker would want to sell their prized asset which in the current market is totally understandable,just not enough to go around at the best of times in recent years & Watkins is proven over 5 seasons in the premier league with his goal contributions over the last couple of seasons up there with the best in Europes top 5 leagues,his assists numbers are very impressive compared to most out & out strikers,a model professional who rarely gets injured, availability is very important,I believe Watkins will be good for a number of years moving forward because he really takes care of himself….UTFV!!!
Here we go ramsdale………….. I think he will fight it out with ramsdale
I’m old fashioned, I like goalkeepers who can save shots. Ramsdale is a minging keeper.
Great video. I mean i'm not jumping for joy at the signing but I can see the point that we can spend the money elsewhere and next Summer there won't be as many clubs looking hopefully. Just hope Eddie can get a tune out of him, by all accounts a well liked guy so will certainly fit in, in the dressing room.
Thanks for putting this together for us mate. Brilliant as always and very much appreciated 👏🏻 😊
If Eddie feels Ramsdale he is an upgrade to the squad in general then a loan sense makes sense. This allows the option to see how he turns out, and buys time should we feel we need another keeper next year. It's hard to judge him based on the defense he had in front of him last season, and I given the history of success I have to believe Eddie knows what he's doing.
im a lot happier about the signing after this video, thanks
Marmadashvili before LiVARpool ??? Sesko is never coming with his options? Total Bollocks. Fcuking right, I’m beyond fcuking depressed.
He is possibly not the answer long term (then again Howe improves players massively so who knows) but just off those in possession stats show that Ramsdale could be a game changer.
I love Nick Pope. But he puts our defenders under pressure too many times. Also the times he kicks it out for a throw – in the Champions League especially, top teams can punish any mistake. Those small moments could make all the difference. Especially when holding on for a result
The lads got a season to prove himself. This isn't a player that Improves us to the level we expected after winning the cup and finishing 5th. Let's hope that the money saved on a keeper goes on the quality we need in other positions.
Next season we can go big for a proper long term keeper.
Thanks again Antonio, you're analysis is excellent as usual mate.
As we didn't seem to have had an alternative if we didn't get Trafford this deal makes sense as good cover for a year until we do.