Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal and Tottenham were notified of ManCity’s guilty verdict before the rest of the league. In September 2024, they were the four Premier League clubs that gave ManCity legal notice of their right to seek compensation.

    by Yours-only2

    Share.

    22 Comments

    1. Excerpts from Full Article here:

      The four Premier League clubs who reserved their rights to seek compensation from Manchester City were notified of the guilty verdict last month before the rest of the league.

      Telegraph Sport understands that Manchester United, Liverpool, Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur were all contacted in advance of the email to the other 15 clubs on Sept 25 – one which required executives to sign a non-disclosure agreement to view. In September 2024, shortly before the six-year limit on giving notice to seek damages in the event of a guilty verdict for City, the four clubs individually notified City they would reserve the right to do so.

      Neither United, Liverpool, Arsenal or Spurs would comment on the early notification when contacted. The Premier League declined to comment. In September 2024, the four clubs had instructed legal counsel individually to give notice they reserved the right to seek compensation before the six-year time limit ran out on the original disclosures about City’s finances, published in Der Spiegel in Germany.

      At the time there was no means by which any Premier League club could contact the independent commission itself to be advised on whether, in the event of one or more guilty verdicts against City, the issue of compensation would play a role in the judgment, or potential sanctioning.

      The rest of the Premier League shareholders at the time, including Chelsea, who subsequently faced Premier League and Football Association charges over historic wrongdoing, declined to give notice. That is not thought to preclude those clubs from compensation claims although it may complicate the procedure.
      City were found guilty of all but one of the Premier League charges in what amounted to a deeply critical verdict from the commission – the members of which have not yet been named – that was published seven days ago. The core decision document, as it was known, ran to 40 pages and was heavily redacted in parts. There are also extensive appendices to the decision which are yet to be published and would play a role in specific compensation claims.
      What were the 115 charges brought against Man City?
      Breakdown of breaches
      54 Failure to provide accurate financial information from 2009-10 to 2017-18
      14 Failure to provide accurate details for player and manager payments from 2009-10 to 2017-18

      5 Failure to comply with Uefa’s rules including financial fair play (FFP) from 2013-14 to 2017-18

      7 Breaching Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules (PSR) from 2015-16 to 2017-18

      35 Failure to co-operate with Premier League investigations from December 2018 to February 2023

      The question of compensation hangs over the outcome of the process, with Burnley having already been given an award of £35m against Everton relating to the 2021-22 season. Everton, who are appealing, were subsequently found to have breached financial controls in the 2021-22 season, at the end of which Burnley were relegated in 18th place.

      City have given notice that they will appeal the verdict which will be heard by a newly assembled three-person commission. The appeal commission has to return a decision, under Premier League rules, within 12 weeks – giving a deadline of Jan 21. The club say it has “a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence”. Upon announcing its appeal, City said that the verdict comprised “on multiple grounds, the opinion contains clear material errors, of law, principle and fact and is unsafe”.

      A successful appeal would have to demonstrate that the three people on the commission made material errors on points of law or procedural mistakes. The commission found the club had benefited from more than £920m to its bottom line between 2009 and 2018 with £830m from what was described as “sham contracts” – sponsorship deals inflated by back-channelled funds from City’s owner, the Abu Dhabi United Group.

      Kyle Walker, the former Manchester City right-back now at Burnley, who won six Premier League titles with City, told Talksport radio: “Obviously it doesn’t look great. I know it’s in an appeal stage so, for me to start commenting on the legal action and everything like that, probably it’s not going to do myself justice or anyone involved in it.

      “But, at a personal level, I can say the lads, we spent many and many a great year celebrating many trophies and everything like that. That’s something that, whatever happens, they can’t take away from us because we’ve experienced those nights. So, whatever will be, will be, and it’s just down to the appeal now and what goes from there.”

    2. MurkyPotato3434 on

      >“But, at a personal level, I can say the lads, we spent many and many a great year celebrating many trophies and everything like that. That’s something that, whatever happens, they can’t take away from us because we’ve experienced those nights. So, whatever will be, will be, and it’s just down to the appeal now and what goes from there.”

      I feel the same way, Kyle.

    3. So having what appears to have been an editorial role in the writing of that garbage report, they then needed to be notified of the result?

    4. Red mafia and spurs getting to find out before the rest of the league sure is weird

    5. bigheadsociety on

      Arsenal and spurs being in the list doesnt make sense seeing as they never finished 2nd behind us during the time period the charges were for.

    6. Sounds like some clubs may have behind/involved in the “independent” investigation 🤔

    7. Independent my arse, the more this goes on the more I’m convinced it’s a stitch up.

    8. GonePostalRoute on

      This is why I’m all for taking this as far as it can go. More and more it’s looking like the red cartel was trying something

    9. And they will act like the Red Cartel is a conspiracy 😂. These clubs are behind the charges. These clubs will be exposed one day.

    10. Acrobatic_Golf9325 on

      Chelsea not being included could mean they’re probably getting an FFP case as well

    11. What I don’t quite get about compensation claims by other clubs is, City are one team out of 20 in the PL. If they’d won other games where they didn’t, then surely they would still have a CL spot?. Granted they feel aggrieved that city are better than them, but what about all the other teams in the league where results didn’t go their way.
      Is the argument that city shouldn’t have been in a CL spot? No way to quantify that.

      Plus look at the last few seasons, it’s not city’s fault that united and spurs are shit…

    12. What a coincidence, I was just watching Typical City’s latest update on the red cartel right before this was posted.

    13. witness_smile on

      Further proof that the hearings and process were totally and entirely impartial and unbiased