Newcastle transfer news: Sandro Tonali’s agent is currently pushing for a permanent move away from St James’ Park this summer. Former Manchester City financial expert Stefan Borson shared this update with Football Insider. He suggests this move marks a major shift in the Newcastle squad. Borson believes Tonali’s potential exit actually secures Bruno Guimaraes’ future at the club. This comes despite constant rumours linking the Brazilian midfielder to Manchester United.
Headlines often link Guimaraes to Old Trafford. However, Borson dismisses these stories as nonsense. Guimaraes turns 29 this November. Financial departments across Europe now prioritise younger talent. Most clubs set a limit of around 26 years of age for massive transfer fees.
Newcastle United simply cannot afford to sell every star player in a single window. This makes a double departure highly unlikely for Eddie Howe’s side. Borson argues that today’s market demands a more careful approach toward older players. This reality directly impacts how other clubs value Guimaraes.
Tonali’s agent sees a chance to arrange a move back to Europe or to a rival giant. This situation puts Newcastle in a tough spot. They must balance their finances while keeping a competitive starting lineup.
“I think the story is nonsense. He’s 29 in November. I just don’t believe that story at all. There’s nothing more to say. I just don’t think 29-year-old players are going to move for those sorts of fees very often anymore. It’s just not the way the world works these days. Everybody’s focused on almost a 26-year-old limit for that sort of money. In any event, Newcastle can’t sell everybody.”
Newcastle transfer news: Why would Newcastle United prefer Tonali’s exit over Guimaraes’ departure?
The Italian midfielder turned 25 during a rocky 2025/26 season. He showed sparks of creativity but struggled with inconsistent physical stats. Tonali offers great ball progression and smart play. However, his recent form suggests he does not fit perfectly into the current Newcastle system. The Magpies have set a valuation of £100 million, which is proof of his high skill level and his regular role for the Italian national team.
Newcastle transfer news: Sandro Tonali’s vision remains world-class. Even so, his defensive speed sometimes drops against fast Premier League teams. If they sell Tonali, it allows Newcastle to keep Guimaraes’ leadership and strength. These qualities form the backbone of their European goals this year. Keeping a 28-year-old Guimaraes over a restless Tonali makes strategic sense. The Brazilian offers more immediate stability, and this choice will protect the team’s morale and get the best value from a player who no longer feels at home in England.
Rohit Sarkar
Rohit Sarkar is a passionate writer with a deep love for multiple sports, but his favourites are football and cricket. Since 2017, he has been covering football and cricket news with a keen eye for detail and compelling storytelling. He is a fan of the beautiful game and a specialist…