* Sky Sports News understands **they have still not made contact with any other potential candidates.**
* **The overriding feeling is there is no need to rush into a decision** when the team is performing so well.
* Carrick’s record (…) led to calls for him to be appointed head coach now.
* But the United powerbrokers will continue to ignore those calls, until such time as they are convinced Carrick is the right man to take the club forward long-term.
* **If United decide to appoint someone else, they are determined that it will be a manager of stature and experience, who can cope with the magnitude of the job and the media scrutiny**
PitchSafe on
If there is a possibility to get one of the best managers like Nagelsmann or Enrique then we should do it. If the other options are De Zebri, Silva, Howe or Glasner then I’m happy with Carrick
Heisenberg_235 on
This isn’t good.
We should’ve been having these initial conversations already. Nothing concrete but just sounding out interest.
neofederalist on
Smart. The goal right now is ensuring CL qualification. Don’t create or fuel any distractions for the players or coaching staff this season.
jim3455 on
Securing Champions League football would essentially turn Carrick from an interim solution into the frontrunner for the United job .
Standard-Height2276 on
If true that’s a huge problem. When do they start? After the season ends after the world cup? I refuse to believe it’s the case that they’re talking to noone. More likely that just nothings leaked out
Educational-Shock232 on
Of course they haven’t, Carrick was the perm manager the moment he signed up in Jan. It means the board don’t have to do their job and work hard to prise a best in class manager out of their current club (ie Enrique). Carrick is cheap and will do as he’s told, it’s just a massive bonus for the board that he’s been doing well.
Lord_Sesshoumaru77 on
Well, currently I don’t think there’s any available manager that we could go after. I’m not taking Xabi Alonso in contention due to his scouser past and his dismal RM tenure. If he crashed there, don’t think he has the minerals to make it here.
Darthkhydaeus on
Secure CL. Then interview. I will be disappointed if there are no interviews regardless of who gets the job.
OptiPath on
If Carrick takes up to CL, he should be given at least 1 full year
spiralism on
I imagine it’s cos the other candidates currently have jobs.
Personally I’m of the opinion that if Lucho is available, it should be him. If not, keep Carrick.
K-manPilkers on
Top tier managers: Pep, Klopp, Ancelotti, Enrique
The first two are out by default. Ancelotti has signed an extension with Brazil so the only way he becomes available is if Brazil sack him if they flop at the World Cup – which is unlikely. Also Madrid will be looking for a permanent coach and the on again off again relationship with Don Carlo would continue if he was interested. The rumours surrounding Enrique looking to leave PSG seem to have died down and even if he does, Man City seems like the obvious destination if Pep goes.
Outside of those, who is a sure bet to be better than Carrick? Arguably Xabi Alonso, but once again the Liverpool connection makes it unlikely. Zidane? Waiting for the France job. Nagelsmann? What has he done? De Zerbi? See Nagelsmann.
Basically if we can sign Enrique, then go for it but if we keep our performances up to the end of the season there really wouldn’t be any other stand out candidate that you could safely say is a better bet than the Carrick/Holland coaching ticket.
craptionbot on
Honestly, Carrick deserves the full time role and I don’t care who is available/unavailable.
We’re in this predicament because fans cried loud, hard, and unfairly so about Ole before a ball was kicked in his final season demanding things like a title run even though Arteta was performing poorer and yet the club did right by him and didn’t cave. Plus he had a board that actually signed the players he wanted rather than a Woodward buzzing around making pointless club signings like Telles, Van De Beek, Fred, Pellestri, Amad (great now but not what was required at all at the time), Cavani etc etc and then panic buying Ronaldo because he threatened to move to City like a proper club legend.
Now here we are where they are terrified of history repeating – which would be a fucking huge improvement of where we’ve been in the league since Ole – and they’re in a flap.
Believe me, the juju will return if Carrick leaves and we’ll be in a cycle of:
* Carrick finishing in 3rd ***in spite of*** Amorim’s sloth-like start and haemorrhaging results
* Carrick losing his job even though he’s done it perfectly well and we lose the unit of Carrick/Holland/Woodgate and/or keep some Frankenstein version of it for “continuity”
* Tuchel/whatever “big name manager” comes in who doesn’t get the club but we squeeze out some good initial results
* The inevitable happens – whatever way you read this should tell you everything you need to know – if your mind went to “shit, not this again” then you know it’s happening, in the unlikely event you thought I meant “we’ll inevitably charge for the title” – wow. Pure delusion.
* We end up in another cycle of “if only we had kept this manager on” and the club will feel that they absolutely can’t go back to Carrick
Keep him, he’s doing great, the structure may not be perfect but fuck me is it not a 500% improvement on what Ole had to work with, and back this man and the people around him to build a team that plays like Manchester United.
BishhEzz on
Should be Naaglesman, Enrique high press football isn’t possible with our squad.
Otter269 on
Surely March break is the time to contact club managers.
JosePRizaI on
You would think with the new ownership United will be ran differently. But here we are. Just Ed Woowarding it again. Freestyle it and make up as you go.
Biggest club in the england that
DerpTagTheSlaya on
People are so quick to pick up arms but in reality no serious manager is going to entertain such conversations during the business end of the season and it’s WC year for current national team managers too. None of the currently unemployed bunch really excite me other than maybe Xabi but it’s very likely we see him at Anfield soon
guayweiqin on
Why cant we trust one of our own, someone who connects and loves the club and is doing relatively well now and always has to look for shiny toys who may just down tools at the slightest transfer disagreement or hardship
By our logic the pep, zidane and enriques will never see the daylight of elite coaching
18 Comments
**Key points of the article:**
* Sky Sports News understands **they have still not made contact with any other potential candidates.**
* **The overriding feeling is there is no need to rush into a decision** when the team is performing so well.
* Carrick’s record (…) led to calls for him to be appointed head coach now.
* But the United powerbrokers will continue to ignore those calls, until such time as they are convinced Carrick is the right man to take the club forward long-term.
* **If United decide to appoint someone else, they are determined that it will be a manager of stature and experience, who can cope with the magnitude of the job and the media scrutiny**
If there is a possibility to get one of the best managers like Nagelsmann or Enrique then we should do it. If the other options are De Zebri, Silva, Howe or Glasner then I’m happy with Carrick
This isn’t good.
We should’ve been having these initial conversations already. Nothing concrete but just sounding out interest.
Smart. The goal right now is ensuring CL qualification. Don’t create or fuel any distractions for the players or coaching staff this season.
Securing Champions League football would essentially turn Carrick from an interim solution into the frontrunner for the United job .
If true that’s a huge problem. When do they start? After the season ends after the world cup? I refuse to believe it’s the case that they’re talking to noone. More likely that just nothings leaked out
Of course they haven’t, Carrick was the perm manager the moment he signed up in Jan. It means the board don’t have to do their job and work hard to prise a best in class manager out of their current club (ie Enrique). Carrick is cheap and will do as he’s told, it’s just a massive bonus for the board that he’s been doing well.
Well, currently I don’t think there’s any available manager that we could go after. I’m not taking Xabi Alonso in contention due to his scouser past and his dismal RM tenure. If he crashed there, don’t think he has the minerals to make it here.
Secure CL. Then interview. I will be disappointed if there are no interviews regardless of who gets the job.
If Carrick takes up to CL, he should be given at least 1 full year
I imagine it’s cos the other candidates currently have jobs.
Personally I’m of the opinion that if Lucho is available, it should be him. If not, keep Carrick.
Top tier managers: Pep, Klopp, Ancelotti, Enrique
The first two are out by default. Ancelotti has signed an extension with Brazil so the only way he becomes available is if Brazil sack him if they flop at the World Cup – which is unlikely. Also Madrid will be looking for a permanent coach and the on again off again relationship with Don Carlo would continue if he was interested. The rumours surrounding Enrique looking to leave PSG seem to have died down and even if he does, Man City seems like the obvious destination if Pep goes.
Outside of those, who is a sure bet to be better than Carrick? Arguably Xabi Alonso, but once again the Liverpool connection makes it unlikely. Zidane? Waiting for the France job. Nagelsmann? What has he done? De Zerbi? See Nagelsmann.
Basically if we can sign Enrique, then go for it but if we keep our performances up to the end of the season there really wouldn’t be any other stand out candidate that you could safely say is a better bet than the Carrick/Holland coaching ticket.
Honestly, Carrick deserves the full time role and I don’t care who is available/unavailable.
We’re in this predicament because fans cried loud, hard, and unfairly so about Ole before a ball was kicked in his final season demanding things like a title run even though Arteta was performing poorer and yet the club did right by him and didn’t cave. Plus he had a board that actually signed the players he wanted rather than a Woodward buzzing around making pointless club signings like Telles, Van De Beek, Fred, Pellestri, Amad (great now but not what was required at all at the time), Cavani etc etc and then panic buying Ronaldo because he threatened to move to City like a proper club legend.
Now here we are where they are terrified of history repeating – which would be a fucking huge improvement of where we’ve been in the league since Ole – and they’re in a flap.
Believe me, the juju will return if Carrick leaves and we’ll be in a cycle of:
* Carrick finishing in 3rd ***in spite of*** Amorim’s sloth-like start and haemorrhaging results
* Carrick losing his job even though he’s done it perfectly well and we lose the unit of Carrick/Holland/Woodgate and/or keep some Frankenstein version of it for “continuity”
* Tuchel/whatever “big name manager” comes in who doesn’t get the club but we squeeze out some good initial results
* The inevitable happens – whatever way you read this should tell you everything you need to know – if your mind went to “shit, not this again” then you know it’s happening, in the unlikely event you thought I meant “we’ll inevitably charge for the title” – wow. Pure delusion.
* We end up in another cycle of “if only we had kept this manager on” and the club will feel that they absolutely can’t go back to Carrick
Keep him, he’s doing great, the structure may not be perfect but fuck me is it not a 500% improvement on what Ole had to work with, and back this man and the people around him to build a team that plays like Manchester United.
Should be Naaglesman, Enrique high press football isn’t possible with our squad.
Surely March break is the time to contact club managers.
You would think with the new ownership United will be ran differently. But here we are. Just Ed Woowarding it again. Freestyle it and make up as you go.
Biggest club in the england that
People are so quick to pick up arms but in reality no serious manager is going to entertain such conversations during the business end of the season and it’s WC year for current national team managers too. None of the currently unemployed bunch really excite me other than maybe Xabi but it’s very likely we see him at Anfield soon
Why cant we trust one of our own, someone who connects and loves the club and is doing relatively well now and always has to look for shiny toys who may just down tools at the slightest transfer disagreement or hardship
By our logic the pep, zidane and enriques will never see the daylight of elite coaching