Share Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Bluesky Threads Honestly,,, who has the better collection of trophies? by Union_1205 newcastle united newcastle united football club
dennis3282 on March 21, 2026 1:59 pm Probably hated for this, but Sunderland. I’d rather win 2 league titles than 4 FA Cups. But…. recency also counts. A league title over 100 years ago doesn’t matter as much. And we have the mighty carabao.
SKULL1138 on March 21, 2026 2:00 pm I mean, we have more, I also don’t see our European trophy from 69 here?
074DanBurn058 on March 21, 2026 2:03 pm League titles are pretty much irrelevant here. In fact, pretty much everything else is
Donnermeat_and_chips on March 21, 2026 2:06 pm Don’t see the Papa John’s margarita pizza cup or the mighty intertoto on here
WillHay108 on March 21, 2026 2:06 pm If it was Premier Leagues vs the old leagues, I’d say them. But the FA Cup was absolutely huge when we were winning things, so I’d say us.
Cactious-Practice on March 21, 2026 2:08 pm You forgot to include Sunderlands third tier trophies and Newcastles Intertoto cup win.
12 Comments
Probably hated for this, but Sunderland.
I’d rather win 2 league titles than 4 FA Cups.
But…. recency also counts. A league title over 100 years ago doesn’t matter as much. And we have the mighty carabao.
We have the Carabao cup, that’s all that matters.
Can we not
This is like comparing shit with shit
I mean, we have more, I also don’t see our European trophy from 69 here?
I don’t remember us winning the premier league
League titles are pretty much irrelevant here. In fact, pretty much everything else is
You are lost
Don’t see the Papa John’s margarita pizza cup or the mighty intertoto on here
If it was Premier Leagues vs the old leagues, I’d say them. But the FA Cup was absolutely huge when we were winning things, so I’d say us.
You forgot to include Sunderlands third tier trophies and Newcastles Intertoto cup win.
Errrrrm where’s the Sela cup ?