I mean to an extent yeah. That’s obvious. And we could just do that forever and probably be fine, but I do think making the club more appealing as less of a stepping stone is important if we want to really compete commercially and at a sporting level with Bayern.
You can’t look at their wage bill and then look at ours and wonder how we just can’t win the damn league. We need to retain some of these kids.
No. Haaland, Bellingham & Co, get what they want out of Dortmund (a shop window) but they rarely move the needle when it comes to Dortmund getting closer to winning serious silverware.
bagstone on
It’s so tiring when websites post clickbait questions. So I’ve asked ChatGPT to summarise to save y’all a click and time.
Is Dortmund’s talent‑factory model succeeding sustainably?
– Yes, from a financial and developmental standpoint.
– No, when it comes to sporting ambition and trophy-winning consistency—they keep rebuilding, but aren’t yet regular title contenders.
Popular_Tomorrow_204 on
Espn with the best quality content we know and love…
greekch1mera on
Borussia Dortmund is like the GreenBay Packers…great tradition, great atmosphere, everyone really proud about the club…but then not able to keep key players and also loosing too many games to be able to compete longer and also be really interesting for players
Mahoc_Mahoc on
…of course not.
BagHoldeApe on
Short answer No.
Selling our best players every few years is not sustainable and we don’t succeed.
I do belive there is a way to succeed for us, it is by actually buying slightly older players as well as young talents. Think about what napoli is doing or inter is doing in seria A alot of older worldclass players, I belive we also need a few players like that as well as younger top talents. The younger players get the chance to learn from and play alongside worldclass players and the club gets stability and experience. I am not suggesting that we become a club for the elderly but players that are proven winners can bring in a winning mentally, the bundesliga is an extremely uncompetitve league 90% of games are must win games for us do to how damaged the league is. We are richer than almost all other clubs in the league by a wide margin the league is basicly decidet for us by being consistent, this is something Bayern has perfected winning almost every game almost every year. Older players with expirence can bring in Consistency and since we are better than almost all other clubs we will close the gap to the top and overtake bayern simply by never losing a singel game we are not supposed to.
8 Comments
I mean to an extent yeah. That’s obvious. And we could just do that forever and probably be fine, but I do think making the club more appealing as less of a stepping stone is important if we want to really compete commercially and at a sporting level with Bayern.
You can’t look at their wage bill and then look at ours and wonder how we just can’t win the damn league. We need to retain some of these kids.
Oh wow an ESPN article, I’m sure it’s engaging informative. 😅
No. Haaland, Bellingham & Co, get what they want out of Dortmund (a shop window) but they rarely move the needle when it comes to Dortmund getting closer to winning serious silverware.
It’s so tiring when websites post clickbait questions. So I’ve asked ChatGPT to summarise to save y’all a click and time.
Is Dortmund’s talent‑factory model succeeding sustainably?
– Yes, from a financial and developmental standpoint.
– No, when it comes to sporting ambition and trophy-winning consistency—they keep rebuilding, but aren’t yet regular title contenders.
Espn with the best quality content we know and love…
Borussia Dortmund is like the GreenBay Packers…great tradition, great atmosphere, everyone really proud about the club…but then not able to keep key players and also loosing too many games to be able to compete longer and also be really interesting for players
…of course not.
Short answer No.
Selling our best players every few years is not sustainable and we don’t succeed.
I do belive there is a way to succeed for us, it is by actually buying slightly older players as well as young talents. Think about what napoli is doing or inter is doing in seria A alot of older worldclass players, I belive we also need a few players like that as well as younger top talents. The younger players get the chance to learn from and play alongside worldclass players and the club gets stability and experience. I am not suggesting that we become a club for the elderly but players that are proven winners can bring in a winning mentally, the bundesliga is an extremely uncompetitve league 90% of games are must win games for us do to how damaged the league is. We are richer than almost all other clubs in the league by a wide margin the league is basicly decidet for us by being consistent, this is something Bayern has perfected winning almost every game almost every year. Older players with expirence can bring in Consistency and since we are better than almost all other clubs we will close the gap to the top and overtake bayern simply by never losing a singel game we are not supposed to.