Close Menu
    Is Ederson a Problem for Man City?
    World Cup 2026

    Is Ederson a Problem for Man City?



    Is Ederson a Problem for Man City?

    View 36 Comments

    36 Comments

    9. @jakewaterfall5091 on

      Problem is Ederson is PIVOTAL to the build up. Nobody in world football can do it like ederson. Problem is when he’s needed to make a save he’s not always up to it. I love the man to bits after all he’s done in the sticks for us. But I’m torn, can’t have any passengers at this level.

    12. @Namesake47 on

      As a city fan I understand people who don't support the club to blame Ederson, though he definitely isn't as good as he used to be he isn't to blame for City's failures because until now he's always been ahead of a class DM from Fernandinho to Rodri who have acted as an anchor for his time but our defence as a whole has crumbled without Rodri, not to mention against Liverpool how sloppy Berando was in his passing and gundo wasn't on his greatest, in my opinion we sign Šeško and Ederson (CM) in the January window and keep Ederson (GK) to see if he can adapt to The presence of Ederson (CM) in that dm role who I've been rating since tge Europa league final last year

    17. @ben19961 on

      You can’t have a good defence with a bad goalkeeper and city have had a good defence since he’s joined it’s insane that you say he’s overrated

    19. @kyngrizzy123 on

      Sometimes i wonder why you people come on here and talk all kind of shit! How can someone won 6 prem and a champions league between the sticks and be overrated man shut tf up. Form is temporary class is permanent

    23. @easonproject9156 on

      Ederson is great for his playmaking as GK. But in a time where defense is frail, he's gonna be exposed. So yea, his gk ability isn't that good and his strength is not useful right now,

    25. @Gonyos on

      His strong point is ball playing GK. Good at kicking ball.

      While Ortega Moreno is truly a goalkeeper and pretty consistent performer.

    27. @Giannis200 on

      A – hermansen stays at Leicester
      B – Man City come in with 70+ million and gets accepted
      C – Chelsea offer an embarrassing 40 million bid

    30. @Kuro45593 on

      I guess this issue is similar to Ter Stegen with Barcelona
      Both are overrated due to their one and only ball playing skills and hated for their shite shot stopping, concentration issues but I think Ederson is still better than Ter Stegen
      Fun fact:- Both Ederson and Ter Stegen once admitted they don't know about Football 😂

    32. @dillonsiv on

      I have always said he was overrated especially when he was compared to guys like Allison. Guys like him and Onna are distribution keepers with subpar shot stopping. One of the main reasons I thought he was so successful was that Pep's playstyle played exactly to his strengths which was possession and minimising the opposing chances, now he has had to face more shots they are paying the price

    34. @artminusme on

      You’re not getting it…. Ederson literally won us the champs league.

      Ederson while a decent shot stopper was bought for being the best distribution keeper in the world… It’s our defense, Walker is done, Ake is done, Stones unfortunately gets injured too often and is now done, for defenders City HAS to go Dias Gvardiol as the CB pair but they need to gel as a duo, Buy a proper LB and a RB.

      Akanji you keep because he’s a great plug and play player in the defense or midfield. Rico you graduate to the middle to learn off the veterans. Sell Grealish, Kovacic, don’t reup B. Silva and Gundo and start again.

      Consider selling Foden for the cash

    Leave A Reply