Fourteen councillors have put their name to a request for a second look at the decision to turn the western end of Western Road into a red route.
The request follows the decision to push ahead with the scheme by Brighton and Hove City Council’s cabinet on Thursday 17 September.
If officials accept the request for a call in, the decision will be questioned at a meeting of the council’s Place Overview and Scrutiny Committee.
Conservative councillor Alistair McNair and Green councillor Ollie Sykes were among the five Tory, seven Green and two Independent councillors who put their name to the request.
At a public meeting, Councillors McNair and Sykes heard first-hand some of the opposition to the red route from traders and residents in the area affected – between Holland Road and Montpelier Road.
Those at the meeting said that the council’s stated reason for turning the road into a red route kept changing. At various times, the council had said that a red route would make it easier to tackle problem parking, improve safety, speed up bus journeys and reduce congestion.
Those objecting to the scheme said that it would reduce access for people with disabilities, make it harder for loading and unloading to take place safely and legally and would ultimately lead to businesses closing.
They said that the character of the road was different to Lewes Road and London Road – main A roads into and out of Brighton – where previous red routes were created.
And they said that the council made the decision without carrying out an economic impact assessment because the real aim was to make money from camera-generated fines.
At the public meeting earlier this month, traders also called for better enforcement of problem parking and said that the few proposed disabled parking and loading bays were inadequate.
They said that the current yellow lines allowed loading and unloading and for people to be picked up and dropped off other than in a few short stretches of the road.
The call-in process is required by the Local Government Act and the way that it operates in Brighton and Hove is set out in the council’s constitution.
The constitution says: “Call-in is the process whereby a key decision taken but not implemented may be examined by an Overview and Scrutiny Committee prior to implementation.
“The Overview and Scrutiny Committee may recommend that the executive reconsider the decision. “The process for call-in (is) six members of the council, including members from at least two political groups or at least one political group plus an independent member or members can call in a key decision of the executive which has been taken but not implemented.
“Key decisions of the executive shall not be implemented for five clear working days following the publication of the decision and a decision can only be called in during this period.
“This rule does not apply to urgent decisions. The notice of the decision will state the date on which the decisions may be implemented if not called in.
“Call-in must be by notification to the chief executive in writing signed by at least six members.”
A call-in request cannot be used just to delay the implementation of a decision. The request must include a valid reason.
The constitution says: “The chief executive, following consultation with the monitoring officer, will consider all call-in requests and may reject requests that do not meet the requirements.”
If a request is accepted, the Overview and Scrutiny Committee should meet within seven working days of the request being received by the chief executive.
The email sent to the chief executive about the red route decision said that the red route decision should be called in because of the absence of sufficient evidence on which to base a decision.
The reasons given were
No Western Road-specific evidence supports the scheme’s stated primary objective.
The report’s summary of the consultation was partial and no written comments including those from businesses were provided
The loading provision is not tested against the council’s own evidence of demand
The economic effect of the scheme is to be assessed only after it is in place
The signatories were all five Conservative councillors – Alistair McNair, Anne Meadows, Carol Theobald, Emma Hogan and Ivan Lyons.
Seven Green councillors supported the call-in request. They were Ollie Sykes, Marina Lademacher, Pete West, Steve Davis, Ellen McLeay, Bruno de Oliveira and Chloe Goldsmith.
Brighton and Hove Independent councillor Mark Earthey and Independent councillor Samer Bagaeen also backed the request.
