While Eddie Howe argued that any club would struggle under the constraints Newcastle face, Aston Villa have disproved that under Unai Emery
Eddie Howe and Unai Emery(Image: PA)
Newcastle boss Eddie Howe ended his press conference after a 2-1 defeat to rivals Sunderland by talking about how financial rules are holding the club back.
While there was little he could say to make the loss any more palatable for Newcastle fans, discussing spending was never going to help. He isn’t wrong – the rules are restrictive – but they cannot be used as an excuse for poor performances on the pitch.
Howe was asked whether the club’s project had lost momentum, and while he agreed, he chose to focus on financial regulations as the main reason.
Losing their top goalscorer, Alexander Isak, was far from ideal, but the club should have sold him much earlier in the summer window to allow time to integrate new signings. Instead, the £120 million duo of Nick Woltemade and Yoane Wissa have managed only eight league goals between them this season, struggling to replace Isak’s impact.
“I think the rules have made it very difficult for that momentum to go with the speed that it initially did,” Howe said on Newcastle’s project losing momentum after defeat to Sunderland. “I don’t know where we can beat that system. We have to follow the rules that are set.
“The club desperately want to be ambitious, but there’s a limit to what we can spend. That has a knock-on effect on everything that we do. The decisions that we made previously, as I say, to not recruit for that many windows. I don’t know a team that wouldn’t suffer from that. We certainly have.
“Then losing Alex last summer was a considerable blow. Again, we can’t feel sorry for ourselves, and we can’t use excuses. We have to find a way to be successful despite all of these things. But with that, I think there has to be an understanding of the tough conditions that we’re in.”
Content cannot be displayed without consent
Newcastle, of course, are not the only club struggling with financial restrictions. Aston Villa have the most in common with the Magpies, with ambitious owners held back in their attempts to spend and drive the club’s progress in every transfer window.
Villa’s commercial revenue is lower than Newcastle’s, and they have played in the Champions League only once under Unai Emery, compared with the Magpies’ two appearances under Howe.
Yet Emery responds to questions about financial rules very differently. While Howe claims the rules are not an excuse but speaks as if they are, Emery has consistently emphasised that Villa are building something special and can harness their “own power.”
Like Newcastle, Villa lack the spending flexibility of some European rivals. But Emery’s refusal to blame regulations for poor form is a key reason he galvanises his team. It has also contributed to Villa collecting the fourth-most points in the Premier League since his arrival in November 2022.
Despite a net spend lower than most clubs in the division during Emery’s tenure, Villa have competed for Champions League football over the past two seasons – and continue to do so in the current campaign. With seven matches remaining, they sit fourth in the Premier League, with a six-point cushion in the Champions League places, while also targeting a trophy, having reached the Europa League quarter-finals.
“We have our own way, and we are confident. We have very good players,” Emery insisted in the January window, after Tottenham gazumped their bid to sign Conor Gallagher.
“We are a huge club, we have fantastic supporters. Villa Park is special, it’s a fortress. But we don’t have the potential to sign, for example, Manchester City signing Semenyo. Like Tottenham signing Gallagher. Okay.
“But we have our own power and we will exploit our capacity. We are positive and we have enough positive energy to get to the challenges that we have – without the power another team can have.”
Howe isn’t wrong to suggest that financial rules have played a role in stalling Newcastle’s momentum, but as Villa have shown under Emery, they cannot be used as the primary explanation.
England’s 2026 World Cup kits
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
Various Prices
England Official Store
Buy Now on England Official Store
England and Nike have launched the new home, away and goalkeeper kits to be worn at this summer’s FIFA World Cup. You can get free delivery on all orders with the code: ENGFREEDEL
Follow our Facebook page!Get more news and AVFC analysis here
The latest Villa headlines sent straight to your phone
Join our Aston Villa WhatsApp group and get the latest breaking news, interviews and opinion sent straight to your phone, plus matchday team news and live updates of all the action. Just click on this link and select ‘Join Community’ to get started. The only proviso is that you must have WhatsApp on your phone to participate. It’s a free service. No one will be able to see your personal information and you will only receive messages from our Villa writers.
We will not spam your WhatsApp feed with constant messages, but you will receive updates from us daily with the latest Villa news. If you later decide to opt out, just go to the name at the top of your screen and click ‘Exit Group’. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. Click here to read our Privacy Notice