Sir Jim Ratcliffe faces a big decision over Michael Carrick’s future after owning up to mistakes
13:43, 05 Mar 2026Updated 13:44, 05 Mar 2026
Michael Carrick suffered his first defeat as interim boss at Newcastle(Image: George Wood/Getty Images)
Sir Jim Ratcliffe was given fresh cause for reflection as Manchester United’s new manager momentum came to a halt against 10-man Newcastle.
Michael Carrick’s unbeaten run as interim boss ended with a 2-1 defeat at St James’ Park, where home midfielder Jacob Ramsey was sent off during a dramatic end to the first half. Anthony Gordon then put Newcastle in front from the penalty spot, only for Casemiro to equalise even later in stoppage time.
United failed to capitalise on their numerical advantage in the second half as Will Osula’s stunning solo goal secured the points for Eddie Howe’s team. The loss hasn’t undone Carrick’s positive impact since he stepped in following Ruben Amorim’s dismissal, and he remains a potential candidate for the permanent role come summer.
FOLLOW OUR MAN UNITED FB PAGE! Latest news and analysis via the MEN’s Manchester United Facebook page
Ratcliffe’s error
Ratcliffe will exercise particular caution over his next appointment after acknowledging the club erred in granting Erik ten Hag a one-year extension. The Dutchman was in charge when the INEOS billionaire invested in the club.
Ten Hag presided over a largely dismal 2023/24 season, redeemed by the FA Cup final triumph over Manchester City. This success contributed to him securing a new contract, only for him to be dismissed the following October and replaced by Amorim.
Ratcliffe later conceded that retaining Ten Hag following the FA Cup victory and appointing Dan Ashworth as sporting director were missteps. Speaking to Sky Sports last year, he said: “I agree the Erik ten Tag and Dan Ashworth decisions were errors. I think there were some mitigating circumstances, but ultimately they were errors. I accept that and I apologise for that.”
Ratcliffe admitted he got it wrong by extending Erik ten Hag’s contract(Image: Manchester United via Getty Images)
Carrick summoned
It’s clear that Ratcliffe has been impressed by Carrick’s management of a team that seemed rudderless under Amorim. Following January’s victory over league leaders Arsenal, Carrick delayed his post-match media obligations to have a private conversation with Ratcliffe.
When questioned about his interaction with the United co-owner, Carrick told Viaplay: “No, not much as you would expect, I think. There’s a lot of happy bodies around the camp today and he’s delighted as well. So it was nice to see him.”
The exchange hinted at an already positive relationship between the manager and his boss
Carrick has impressed Ratcliffe(Image: Marc Atkins/Getty Images)
Tense interview
Understandably, Carrick wasn’t in high spirits after the loss at Newcastle. However, his mood seemed to sour further when TNT Sports reporter Jules Breach suggested his team had lacked character.
She asked: “You’ve shown so much character in your games, why was that lacking?” Carrick quickly retorted: “It wasn’t. It wasn’t.” A palpable silence followed, and Breach was heard to say: “Okay.”
Carrick bristled at questions following the defeat at Newcastle(Image: TNT Sports)
Carrick continued: “It’s easy to feel that just because you don’t win a game of football. Just general things, the quality.”
The ex-midfielder provided another terse response when asked to elaborate on what was lacking in the performance. He said: “We’ve lost one game, alright? We haven’t played well enough, but in the grand scheme of things, we’re in a decent position.”
Sky Sports discounted Premier League and EFL package
This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more
£49
£35
Sky
Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle for the 2025/26 season, saving £336 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.
Sky shows at least 215 live Premier League games each season, an increase of up to 100, plus Formula 1, darts, golf and more.